ASD in Virginia Woolf’s The Waves

The older I get, the more I try to fill in my numerous reading gaps. These holes are huge when it comes to contemporary writing—unfillable really, I manage to read only a few new memoir and poetry titles—most of the time I’m reading older literature that I should have read by now. It took decades to get to Proust and Musil. War and Peace. Michel Leiris.

 

A review of Katharine Smyth’s All the Lives We Ever Lived: Seeking Solace in Virginia Woolf intrigued me and so I reread To the Lighthouse to follow Smyth’s contemplation of the Woolf novel alongside her father’s death. The reviewer had quoted Smyth’s poignant question about the ultimate value of writing her book: “Have I come up with anything, has Woolf come up with anything, that is more than circling a brutal truth?” For Smyth, the “brutal truth” is mortality and our seeming incapacity to discover anything “that could lessen loss.” This question and its implications—whether writing does anything more than ineffectively circle what it can’t face directly because nothing we create can ameliorate anything—is something I often consider. Writing can be as intensely enjoyable as it’s demanding, and it makes a small amount of sense to be grateful for whatever it is inside that fashions a well-crafted piece of writing, but I certainly don’t believe that anything I could create has any value apart from a literary one. And even that I can’t be sure about.

 

I admire Smyth for her difficult question, and to include Woolf in it strikes deeply—if most people don’t think about death until they’re forced to, it’s also true that people, if they’re honest, also don’t wish to countenance that art, especially a masterpiece like To the Lighthouse, cannot engage meaningfully with mortality. This is logical on one hand—how could a human construction respond to the obliteration of the human?—but on the other hand, it’s also curious: Woolf’s novel and art in general is obsessed with transience. Why then can’t this obsession lead to solace? Here’s the next blunt question: if art has no ultimate value, why spend one’s life trying to create it?

 

(Lily may have her vision, complete her painting exactly as needed, but inevitable oblivion awaits.)

 

We’re in a murky place now. Without necessarily declaring it to be so, it isn’t uncommon for people to believe in a hazy way that art has the capacity to transcend reality. To allow that art may at best allow us to perceive our fears as we circle them or at worst be a highly complicated game but no more, is an unwelcome thought. Why do I write poetry? An honest and perhaps unsatisfactory reply is that I just don’t know how to stop.[1] It’s fun. It’s beguiling to work on something that can’t be predicted and at the same time be that activity over which I have the most control. Or to be slightly zany: poetry doesn’t deny anything; rather, it tries for things people haven’t.

 (One of the artists I most admire, Andrey Tarkovsky, would likely agree with the notion that poetry, or film for that matter, aims to come at existence from a different angle than cause and effect, or history, or even desire, but his religious sensibility would repudiate my refusal to grant art a transcendental function. “In short, the meaning of art,” he claims, “is the search for God in man.” His overall aesthetic can be gleaned from a short meditation he offers on the image:

 

“An artistic image is one that ensures its own development. The image is a grain, a self-evolving retroactive organism. It is the symbol of actual life, as opposed to life itself. Life contains death. An image of life, by contrast, excludes it, or else sees in it a unique potential for the affirmation of life. Whatever it expresses—even destruction and ruin—the artistic image is by definition an embodiment of hope, it is inspired by faith. Artistic creation is by definition a denial of death. Therefore it is optimistic; even if in an ultimate sense the artist is tragic.”

 

Yes to the image (or poem) as a grain, a self-evolving retroactive organism; the search for God in man—I just don’t get it.)

 

Time for a detour.

 

Nearly three decades ago when I got a job teaching, a recently retired professor stood in the doorway to my office and let me know that nothing we write matters. He’d made a name for himself as a scholar of the Raj and had published two novels—but these accomplishments had no lasting importance to him. That he’d chosen to make this announcement to a freshly hired English professor was amusing. I admired his candor. Our offices were next to each other, and we got along well. Over the years he’d poke his head in and ask me whether I was still working on my poetry, and he’d chuckle. Eventually he was forced to give up his office. The last time I saw him was in a grocery store: I greeted him but after some conversation realized that he had no idea who I was—he asked whether I was a former student—and his previous dismissal of his own work (and by implication everyone’s) came back to me. A career of editing Indian authors, writing introductions, reviews. articles and his own fiction came merely to that frayed moment, he staring at me, not frantic but anxious that nothing made sense in my greeting him. I noticed that his shopping basket was filled mostly with crackers and melba toast.

 

*

 

I’ve read the major Woolf novels but had always put off The Waves, to be honest because I thought it might be a bit of a slog. All I knew was that it was composed of disembodied voices. But then I came across Jan Zwicky’s remarks in Once Upon a Time in the West:

 

“To try to make sense of one’s life is to gather one’s own and the community’s memories and to attempt to produce some kind of fit. But this project is continually undone by the world., by deep, open attention to the world. No one voices this difficulty more brilliantly than Virginia Woolf in The Waves—Bernard’s long closing soliloquy, or Rhoda’s reaction to Percival’s death. Indeed, the structure of this intended prose meditation—is it a novel?—embodies that sensation.”

 

Zwicky’s recommendation clinched it.

 

I turned to The Waves a couple of months ago and was eager to see what Zwicky meant. One reading is rarely enough for any book, but this one especially required a second reading. Zwicky’s use of Woolf to clarify her point about lyric thought makes splendid sense; reading the two writers together enhances one’s understanding of each. I’m glad I waited to read the book. I don’t know how much of it would have spoken to me when I was an undergraduate encountering Woolf for the first time. Certainly, it was propitious that I’d waited until I gained some knowledge about ASD.

 

Rhoda’s pessimism instantly appealed to me but when I came across her commenting that the world of other people “is the real world,” and that her way of behaving socially requires her “to look first and do what other people do when they have done it,” I asked myself whether Woolf had created an autistic character. Imitating social behaviour rather than intuitively grasping its mechanics is a classic autistic trait. On my second time through the novel, I paid particular attention to Rhoda’s mode of being in the world and believe that Woolf gave her character a sensibility that embodies what we would now call high-functioning autism. (Various people have theorized that Woolf herself was on the spectrum which seems possible, though I’m hesitant about posthumous diagnoses.) That said, online commentary suggests that numerous people have observed what they believe to be autism in Woolf’s characters. Rhoda’s perpetual anxiety, her sense that she’s “outside of the loop,” her vulnerability to the “shock of sensation,” and more than anything the fact of her suicide (people with ASD are more than 7X likely to commit suicide than so-called normal people)—all these characteristics intimate that Woolf endowed her with a psyche we would now classify as autistic.

 

Various autism scholars have noted how the autistic mind is more rooted in association and discerning resemblance (Julia Miele Rodas) than constructing narrative. The literary critic Kate Flint (who wrote the introduction to my Penguin edition of the novel) remarks how Rhoda’s “language slides quickly away from surfaces; everyday life is made strange by her habit of thinking in similes and through associative patterns.” Flint’s observation is astute, but it nonetheless betrays a neurotypical assessment of the neurodivergent. To the (presumably) neurotypical scholar, Rhoda is strange. To me, she makes perfect sense. Feeling herself “alone in a hostile world,” Rhoda maintains that she should “be hung with other people like a joint of meat among other joints of meat.”

 

(Shades of both Francis Bacon and Rainer Maria Fassbinder’s slaughterhouse scene in Berlin Alexanderplatz.)

 

Following this nihilistic comparison—though what is nihilism but an honest analysis / perception of reality?—Rhoda spins out a number of similes only to recoil against them. “`Like’ and `like’ and `like’—but what is the thing that lies beneath the semblance of the thing?” Enter the autistic as metaphysician. While a penchant for metaphysics is obviously not the sole domain of folks with ASD, I often wonder whether for us the desire to get at reality is a necessity rather than a philosophical interest.[2] To Matthew K. Belmonte, the difficulties autistic people face in social perception mean that they “must concentrate harder to construct a theory of reality, to pierce it together from perceptual fragments.” Belmonte goes one step further in his essay “Human, but More So: What the Autistic Brain Tells Us About the Process of Narrative,” arguing that autistic neurobiology makes it difficult for autistics to join events into sequence and construct narratives.

 

Rhoda would presumably repudiate Bernard’s take on conventional life:

 

“Something always has to be done next. Tuesday follows Monday; Wednesday Tuesday . . . What was fiery and furtive like a fling of grain cast into the air and blown hither and thither by wild gusts of life from every quarter is now methodical and orderly and flung with a purpose—so it seems.”

 

Bernard questions this propensity to bestow order through narrative, but he can’t resist stories because “if there are no stories, what end can there be, or what beginning?”

 

Exactly, Rhoda might say: there is only the fiery and furtive, and tying together these fragments into a story tames them and disregards their integrity. If, to return to Belmonte, “it is precisely this narrative disruption that elicits an unusually deliberate effort to construct reality,” he also observes that a “fear of death drives us to become narrators,” and that this strategy is “ultimately futile.” Autistic people like Rhoda refuse to sacrifice the detail to narrative. They are familiar with futility.

 

I’ve always wondered why I’ve been utterly suspicious of narrative and although I published a collection of short stories, I’ve found devising plot extraordinarily difficult. Ever since I was in my teens, I’ve been told I “miss the forest for the trees.” It is details I retain in memory, and it is details that speak to me. The writers I most love—Melville in Moby-Dick, Proust—ignore narrative largely, preferring facts, details, lists, moments.

 

Two things: learning about ASD has shaken my sense of self. Some people find diagnosis to be liberating; I’ve found it’s like falling backwards into an elevator shaft. I thought that my life-long interest in philosophy and in particular phenomenology and what became known as Affect Theory (as practiced by Lauren Berlant and Kathleen Stewart) was simply that: an interest. But an interest that’s been freely chosen. If Belmonte is correct, then these philosophical concerns were driven by psychic necessity.[3] To survive the chaos of events, and especially the bewildering social world, those of us on the spectrum must assess the nature of reality as accurately as possible. Here’s the second thing: ASD may be part of evolution; that is, (Belmonte again):

 

“Such comparisons between autistic and neurotypical behavior raise the possibility that a liability to autism may be inevitable in a species whose brain is complex enough to implement narrative organization. In contexts in which attention to detail rather than to theme confers cognitive advantages, people with autism-spectrum conditions and people with the broader autism phenotype tend to excel, suggesting that pseudo-autistic qualities in moderate measure may be adaptive.”

 

So, there’s no right or wrong way to approach reality and social cohesion, right? But it isn’t simply a matter of I prefer my pizza with details and you like heaps of story. Not even remotely. Our society is based on neurotypicality. If you’re a writer, it’s best to go for captivating stories rather than prose poems.

 

Another detour.

 

After I published my short story collection, an esteemed fiction writer whom I much admire asked me what my follow-up project would be. A series of short texts that combines my Polaroid photography with a smattering of lyric prose, I said. The image and text wouldn’t be related in a direct way; rather, they’d dialectically bounce off each other. And about to veer into a lengthy (monotropic) discussion of this exciting form, I was taken back when the famous novelist, biographer and essayist started laughing. You really don’t want to be successful, do you, he said, not asking really. Do what you like but if you want critical attention and a bit of financial success write a novel. Writers cut their teeth on short stories and then move on, he advised.

 

More to the point, most editors just don’t get autistic writing. As Rodas points out, there are “powerful cultural trends demanding adherence to language conventions. . . . Even while autists write themselves into the cultural narrative, asserting their own stories and experience, the expressive language used to relay autistic lives is sanitized, regularized, and normalized.” It has to be this way because, as Thomas Couser argues, “Disabled people may be granted access to the literary marketplace on the condition that their stories conform to preferred paradigms.” Indeed, here is a rejection note I received for an essay I wrote on mental illness and solastalgia:

 

An ambitious and experimental piece with an intriguing hint of environmental collapse. If that's the intended throughline, it would benefit from more clarity. Overall the piece is a little too disjointed and challenging to follow. Consider each vignette on its own. What are you trying to achieve? What are the digressions and footnotes and asides doing for the vignette? Are they pulling the reader's attention in many directions and if so, is this what you intend?

 

Yes, this is what I intend—

 

Perhaps people are more receptive to the autistic mind when it uses poetry, however. I’m going to close with a piece from my collection Realia:

 

 

 

Despite Limited Life Experience

The journey is made almost alone. A raga spun

from the umbilical cord—a telescope

composed of   ◙   sheets of

disintegrating time. A placenta

whose travails are contemplated

by the interactive evolution of pigment

sprinkled across the egg of a heron, a long sliver

of hectic genealogy + screen memories → these melancholy

 

notations the result of brain shrink

and the agoraphobic

peregrinations of the heart: it’s untenable

this toothless struggle to reach

the bottom of the food chain, a target

with room inside

for everyone, these

                    days lifted from the glossy = the quick and dirty

the bodily fluids of the ephemeral, its torrential

everything

                 stripped down,

and botched

to the core ←

 

 


[1]Here let me indulge in the autistic love of collection. When I wrote this sentence, another came to mind, though it took me most of the day to recall the source. Describing the almost pre-consciousness of his character George upon waking, Christopher Isherwood writes in A Single Man: “The creature we are watching will struggle on an on until it drops. Not because it is heroic. It can imagine no alternative.” This judgment lodged in my mind ever since reading it more than forty years ago, a personal memory of no importance to anyone, but I mention it to clarify something about ASD. Autistics very often have precise recall of disparate moments, often jarring ideas and sensations that form the basis of their psychic response to the world.

[2]In addition to ASD, it’s likely that Rhoda has clinical depression. Here is Julia Kristeva channeling someone with depression: “Absent from other people’s meaning, alien, accidental with respect to my naïve happiness, I owe a supreme, metaphysical lucidity to my depression. On the frontiers of life and death, occasionally I have the arrogant feeling of being witness to the meaninglessness of Being, of revealing the absurdity of bonds and beings.”

[3]Thomas Ligotti notes that philosophical inquiry has nothing to do with ascertaining truth; an optimist like Hegel or a pessimist like Schopenhauer is merely following their own psychological make-up. As Ligotti puts it, “all philosophical proclivities [can be reduced] to the psychology of the individuals who exhibit them.”

Previous
Previous

On Being a Symptom: Predictability, PDA and Eventually a Polaroid Photograph

Next
Next

On Being Neurodivergent: Affective Empathy