Photographers, operating within the terms of the Surrealist sensibility, suggest the vanity of even trying to understand the world and instead propose that we collect it.
Susan Sontag, On Photography
Details are compelling and because Polaroid photography especially traffics in the detail it makes sense that my go-to camera is a Polaroid. But why do details jump out at me, why do I collect them, jot them down, mull them over and if I’m lucky, include them in a piece of writing?
Identifying key autistic traits, Donna Henderson, Sarah Wayland and Jamell White argue that “a narrow and intense focus of attention [often called monotropism] is a core feature of autistic nervous systems . . . [Monotropism includes] an ability to focus deeply on an intense interest and attention to detail.” (bold in original)
Herein possibly lies my fascination with Polaroid photographs. A well-composed Polaroid photograph is pure precision, breaking off a fragment of the world and allowing it its own integrity. Let’s move back into theory: a Polaroid image manifests what Julia Miele Rodas sees as one of the typical “thought-units” of “autistic cognition”: the “`local coherence” of the detail. Instead of arriving at global narratives or generalities, autistic people, she claims, “focus on the minute and particular.”
Given that not all photographers are autistic (though recall Andy Warhol’s interest in the Polaroid), what intrigues and disturbs me is the prospect that being a street photographer who prefers to use a Polaroid camera is actually a manifestation of my ASD.
It is bizarre to encounter oneself as a symptom. Can one untangle the self from a chronic neurological disorder? Does it even make sense to think of the self in this way?
Here’s a related question that’s pertinent to day-to-day life, friendships and marriage: what responsibility does one have for explosive emotions if one has ASD (or mental illness, or a learning disability)? Am I responsible for meltdowns? Or to be more positive: loyalty is a virtue, isn’t it? But does it count as such when one learns that people on the spectrum tend to be steadfast to friends? Am I trusting and loyal because of ASD?
What is at the root of my ongoing, sometimes ravenous need for solitude?
Is there a self that resides apart from ASD? According to Jim Sinclair, the question misses the point of an autistic diagnosis. In “Don’t Mourn for Us” he writes:
“Autism isn't something a person has, or a "shell" that a person is trapped inside. There's no normal child hidden behind the autism. Autism is a way of being. It is pervasive; it colors every experience, every sensation, perception, thought, emotion, and encounter, every aspect of existence. It is not possible to separate the autism from the person--and if it were possible, the person you'd have left would not be the same person you started with.”
What Sinclair says rings true, but the flip side is that people can use ASD against you by deliberately shutting you down. Deny you any self at all. “Oh, that’s just your ASD talking right now,” someone might say, effectively rendering your concerns illegitimate.
The more I learn about the intricacies of ASD, the more Sinclair’s observations clarify my life experiences; but a late life diagnosis means that what I’ve perceived as a personal identity, a subjectivity that is mine alone, one that has been honed over decades, is, in fact, very much a symptom of ASD. An elaboration of ASD. Ever since childhood, for example, reading behind a closed door has been integral to a sense of well-being, safety, curiosity; and then later as an adult, I’ve found that ambling about a foreign city taking pictures has provided some of the most fulfilling times of my life. Wandering solo for hours taking everything in, gathering details, is pure joy. Especially in a city in which nobody knows me.
These activities have carved who I am—having read two books a week on average since the age of twelve shapes one’s grasp of things, and recent studies in neuroscience would add that reading this much for so long has created neurological pathways in my brain that are different from the brains of those who don’t care for books. In terms of photography, I think about composition continually. When I look around, indoors or outside, watching a face or a car going by, I find the image taking form as a still photograph. A late diagnosis of ASD rearranges everything. I’m deeply puzzled to learn that these activities, which have seemed so natural to me as part of my identity, correspond precisely with traits associated with ASD.
Let me cite from The Autistic Spectrum by Jill Boucher and then play with her paragraph:
“Leisure activities tend to be predictable for any one individual with an ASD, and often solitary—or at least of a kind that can be enjoyed with or without the company of others. The most able, usually those who live and work without support, enjoy such activities as listening to music, travelling, photography, reading (though novels are almost never on the list), whilst finding informal socializing difficult and stressful.” (emphasis mine)
Predictable?
—to be identified as participating in a predictable pattern is existentially troubling (what, then, could freedom mean?) and minorly insulting to one’s sense of individuality. This is not an uncommon experience for anyone, neurodivergent or neurotypical, realizing one manifests stereotypes of class, generation, gender, but it chaffs one’s sense of independence nonetheless. How many people like to be pigeon-holed, to be told that one’s behaviour is predictable? What about responsibility? Part of being a person is to be responsible for one’s actions, and possibly the thoughts one allows to flourish or prune away. But if Sinclair is correct to say that autism “colors every experience, every sensation, perception, thought, emotion, and encounter, every aspect of existence,” then how certain can I be that an ethical decision is freely made?
(Note: I WILL get to Polaroids, but in true autist fashion, I have to explain so much to get there.)
My sense of who I am now and in the past as someone capable of making independent decisions is entirely undermined. I can’t be certain of anything. Moreover, along with ASD, I have Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA): more than is normal, I react badly when people make demands upon me and the more severe my anxiety has been mounting on a given day, the greater the intensity of my reaction. Something simple—my partner suggesting I not buy more wild bird seed because we have enough—has infuriated me and hurled me into a meltdown. A day became totally derailed—for her and me. Some of the most ugly and intense marital battles I’ve had have happened when I’ve believed that a partner hasn’t granted me autonomy. And I extend autonomy to others. I don’t tell people what to do; I despise having control over another person. But this quality may in fact be another manifestation of a disorder.
According to the British PDA Society: “The avoidance is often associated with an intolerance of uncertainty and feelings of threats to autonomy and usually associated with high anxiety around this. Some PDA individuals refer to PDA as a ‘Pervasive Drive for Autonomy’.”
Here’s the thing: during the moment of intense anger and frustration that overwhelms me when I feel my autonomy has been threatened, I feel justified. Later, I calm down, usually apologize, but the sense of being trodden upon remains. I loathe putting limits on someone else’s autonomy, not so good with raising children, but a positive thing when working with graduate students, say: some professors refuse to give their graduate students freedom; rather, they want their students to mirror their own work, something I find abhorrent.
I simply can’t grasp the love of power. It makes no sense to me that people want to tell others what to do. I’m not a person who joins groups and I don’t wish to control anyone. Is this a reasonable position to take or is this a predictable component of my ASD? I have no way of evaluating this question.
(Here's an oddly loopy characteristic of PDA: the tendency to make up new names for people and animals. Until I learned how annoying this habit can be to new acquaintances, what I often did upon meeting someone when I was a child was automatically give them a different name than their actual one. “Hello,” someone might say, “I’m Jeff.” “Pleased to meet you, Jeff, but just to let you know, I’m going to call you Steve.” I didn’t learn about PDA until a few months ago and when I encountered this personality trait, I then had a better sense of my previous experience. It never occurred to me to ask myself why I used to do this; it seemed to be a normal, natural thing to do. Apparently not.)
Travelling, Photography, Reading
—if I enjoy family trips, there’s a special thrill to solo travelling. Going to an art museum, ditto. But wandering here and there with a camera in unfamiliar places where no one knows me isn’t merely fun; it’s crucial. If I can’t do this when I’m travelling I feel suffocated.
However, when what has been familiar to me since childhood—OCD, stimming, depression, preferring solitude to people and later developing autoimmune diseases—is located on the spectrum, it is disquieting to realize that my favourite activities have not so much been freely chosen as a manifestation of a psychological condition. I’m still trying to understand what this means. Am I anything apart from a bundling of symptoms? To frame this perplexity, recall Lauren Berlant’s recognition that each person has an “irreducible specificity,” but that maintaining (or even achieving) sovereignty as an individual is a “fantasy.” How can one possibly ascertain one’s identity?
—that reading is pleasurable seems obvious, though not to the majority of other people in this society who read almost nothing. It’s a way of escaping solipsism and retaining solitude. It is being embraced by the foreignness of words. I used to love novels but for the past two decades have shifted. I read Proust a few days each week, but I don’t really consider Proust a novelist in the traditional sense—more an early autofictionalist—and the only contemporary novelist whose new work I immediately read is Richard Powers. Memoir yes, creative non-fiction essays, many, also poetry, theory and a smattering of history, but most novels just feel off to me. What used to seem like a philistine attitude that I rejected—the tossed off notion that fiction is about made-up people, hence not to be taken seriously—now echoes my sense that I find it hard to care about the usual novelistic strategies; characters, plot → these devices seem tedious very often.
How can Boucher summarize most of my entire life in a brief paragraph?
Finally: photography.
Despite its reliance on point-of-view, photography.is very different from fiction and the way reading manifests the solitary-communal. (By photography I mean deliberate street photography or the creation of staged images, not family or tourist snapshots.)
I’m learning that a key component of ASD is contradiction and seeming paradox. One needs to adhere to a strict routine and yet resents rules imposed by others. Street photography is similar. It necessitates being open to chance and contingency—something that in actual life produces chaos and anxiety—but one controls this contingency insofar as the camera provides a buffer and confirms outsider status.
Back to the Sontag epigraph: “Photographers, operating within the terms of the Surrealist sensibility, suggest the vanity of even trying to understand the world and instead propose that we collect it.” If Autistic people expend an enormous amount of time and energy to interpret and grasp reality, we are deeply attuned to the absurdity of these efforts.[1] Despite patterns, the world occurs as chaos. Taking a photograph, composing one, plays with repudiating this chaos by granting artistic form. Though form is merely elaborate play. Serious play, though with a gravity that loves the goofy. Or absolutely not. Robert Frank’s perfectly composed Trolley—New Orleans is a long way from being goofy with its grasp of the waste of working lives, the way we repudiate aging. But it takes enormous delight in form, somehow managing to compress just about every important twentieth-century theory of art into its frame.
Glance at this Polaroid—an old-fashioned British telephone booth randomly occurring near a graveyard in a field. Not far from the Bruce Peninsula in Ontario. Impossible not to photograph. The image taken in 2018, just before a woman stepped inside the booth and lifted her top, possibly the first time that had happened precisely there. Out of several shots, this one the best, lines swaying against lines, the sky and the road cousins of a sort. The booth making me wish I had a miniature metal one just like it, to hold and put onto a window ledge, but the picture is better, inviting a viewer but also stepping back, not wanting to have anything to do with people. Not a lick of confusion in the picture, but lots of solitude. Various promises, too, but almost impossible to say of what. They’re just there.
[1]In Autistic Disturbances, Julia Miele Rodas cites Therese Jolliffe: “`Reality to an autistic person is a confusing, interacting mass of events, people, places, sounds and sights. . . Set routines and rituals help to get order into an unbearably chaotic life. Trying to keep everything the same reduces the terrible fear.”