Terence: I am human: nothing human is alien to me.
Most people are familiar with Terence’s remark “I am human: nothing human is alien to me,” or if not with this precise quotation, they’ve come across the general idea that being human gives us access to human experience writ large. This one has always seemed odd to me, hiding more than what it says. Perhaps we share basic emotions, even likely: while I might not find a game of peek-a-boo hilarious anymore, I think we can all say we know what it’s like for a baby to go into giggle-fits over the game. But the idea that nothing can surprise us about the dimensions of being human perplexes me because I think there are numerous experiences and states of mind that one cannot know unless one inhabits them. I have a friend who believes seriously that he has the makings of a serial killer and I have another friend who has told me that he has never in his life felt depressed; external events can cause him distress but what I call the “d,” that terrible force that can persist for weeks, even months and is occasioned by nothing from the external world aimed at you—no, he’s ever suffered that. I believe each of these people. The former partially came to this conclusion when he became aware that his childhood corresponded closely to the history common to many psychopaths, but he’s never committed even a small act of violence against a person. Does he feel surprised by Dahmer? No, he’s told me. Yet there must be an enormous shift in the psyche of someone who has the propensity to perform an action and following through. The Terence intrigues me because as much as it makes an intuitive sense it also seems to be undercut by observation. Most people have had suicidal ideation during their lives but the number of people who find themselves in an ICU after an attempt is fewer.
It is this direction that most intrigues me. Every time I experience turbulence while flying, I wonder if everyone around me is going to join that horrifying club of those who have died in air crashes. If there are things likely everyone knows—fear, sexual jealousy, what it means to laugh—what about those components of human experience that are real but happen rarely in the statistical sense? Moving the thought along a little further, what of aging, developing cancer, or attending enough rock concerts to have hearing damage—these phenomena have been experienced by huge numbers of people, though not everyone. If one wishes to have an understanding of people generally, what is the relationship between having an innate familiarity with the human condition as Terence maintains and belonging to that smaller group who has sat in an oncologist’s office or performed as an actor for a paying audience in a Shakespearean play? I’ve done the former but not the latter and it seems quite clear to me that unless you’ve waited for that knock on the door that most doctors use before entering a room or been Lady Macbeth you don’t really know what it’s like to be human in that particular way.
What would it mean to look at people around you, and then those you’ll never meet but through some media or another, and find them corresponding to what’s inside? Do I understand Ivan Karamozov? His vituperation against a theodicy? Yep. The propensity for addiction that runs in varying degrees through my family. Uh huh. The desire to punish someone who’s hurt you? But then, follow through? Yes. No.
My two sisters and I placed my father’s urn into the ground in our family plot today. I was the one who leaned down into the perfectly carved hole that had been dug beside the family tombstone and placed the heavy box into the soil. There wasn’t anyone in the cemetery this late morning, except the groundskeeper who was waiting for us to say goodbye and then she’d fill in the grave. My youngest sister hated my father and the sister in between her and me was mourning the man who died 4 years ago. My relationship with Dad was jagged. The cemetery is a small one on the outskirts of a small town in southern Ontario. Alice Munro country, someone we talked about on the drive up: my youngest sister decided to toss out all her Munro collections upon learning of the Munro scandal. You find yourself in a cemetery like this and observe two things: somehow there’s an enormous divide: some tombstones mark very long lives indeed—people reaching 80 and more—and then so many children, so many dying before they became 5. We were alone in a place that had contained hundreds of internments. Were these familiar to me? Simply because I’m human? Could they be? No. I haven’t buried a wife. A wife hasn’t buried me. I can hear the wind ripping around this hotel room on the 21st floor as Toronto tilts into its first snow tomorrow. As everyone in Toronto must feel if they walk outside. The siren that passes by just now (as the sound must repeat in every movie that takes place in a city), holds someone in desperate need but for today, it’s not you.
What does anyone want who quotes Terence?
Not sure I can answer that one.
I think it’s kind of brave and kind of silly, though more than a pose. At best, it can restrain judgment over others. And I’m playing chess all night. With whom do you have more in common? The person I met on the elevator to the 21st floor wearing a blue and white hockey jersey or the child in Sick Kids Hospital less than a kilometer from here? Let’s go with the brave. It doesn’t mean solidarity exactly, right? It does reject that most nasty and natural of impulses: the desire to fear and hate the stranger. It refuses the scapegoat as an actuality and a practice. It means that I really get it when someone close to me has spent a life-time burying family and drinks probably ten beers a day and his doctor has identified this as a problem that must be repaired, but the man has been doing this for over twenty years and shifting will require enormous effort and also merely a precise shift in perspective. I’ve been there. As we all have. But, of course, we haven’t equally been there.
And here is the impossible question.
Is there a we? The simple answer is that yes, there has to be, and no, there can’t possibly be.