Readings: John Vaillant’s Fireweather

Readings

 

John Vaillant Fire Weather

 

To grieve openly is to soften to the precarity in our own lives while also looking fiercely into the mirror at how we amplify the precarity in others’ lives.

       Arianne Zwartjes, These Dark Skies

 

The day a wildfire moved into Jasper, I decided it was time to read John Vaillant’s Fireweather: The Making of a Beast, a book I’d been avoiding because I’d anticipated, correctly, that it would nudge me into a low-grade depression and exacerbate my ongoing Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Vaillant’s book provides an almost hour-by-hour account of the fire, but it offers much more than a contextualizing chronology. In balancing nuance and outrage as he charts the long and short history of the Fort McMurray fire, Vaillant offers an ethical critique and even an ontology of combustion and wildfire.

 

It’s hard to know how to respond to this book. Although I’ve been researching and writing about the Anthropocene for years, Fireweather is necessarily brutal reading, especially to Canadians, not only for the benefits we’ve accrued from the resource economy but also our particular vulnerability to wildfire smoke and flooding, those manifestations of global warming that are often most immediate to our experience. As I write this, I’m in a room with an air purifier going; the air quality is at 6. As someone who was an idiot and smoked for decades, my lungs are especially endangered by wildfire particulate. I suppose that having been addicted to cigarettes and then taking a difficult year to quit has shown me something about the way one can live in complete denial of facts. I also know there’s the steady possibility of eventually facing reality: it takes effort, but one can change.

 

I’m skeptical, though, whether an individual’s capacity for breaking an addiction can be extended to a civilization. As George Marshall observes in Don’t Even Think About It: Why Our Brains are Wired to Ignore Climate Change: “The bottom line is that we do not accept climate change because we wish to avoid the anxiety it generates and the deep change it requires.”

 

That recognition of reality is intertwined with changing one’s way of living places climate change in a bewildering category. Although there are similarities between overcoming an addiction and accepting that climate change is real and further, in order to protect ourselves we must alter our behaviour, I think it’s also true that for most of us it’s almost impossible to genuinely take in that what scientists have been warning us about is actually happening. And occurring even faster than they predicted. It’s a strange thing that one can be aware of the facts pertaining to global warming and yet resist letting this knowledge gather heft inside. The ravening anxiety to which Marshall refers is appalling, and I suspect it’s shared by many. Driving around Houston with Timothy Morton, Roy Scranton quotes the eco-philosopher on this very problem in We’re Doomed. Now What?:

 

“We’re in shock, and that’s on a good day. Most days it’s just grief work because we’re in a state of total denial. I am too. I can only allow myself to feel really upset about what’s going on for maybe one second a day, otherwise I’d be in a heap on the floor all the time crying.”

I get what Morton means. And yet, this mood, new perhaps to privileged people in the global north, can also manifest peculiar instances of ordinary cognitive dissonance.

 

Vaillant includes a bizarre anecdote that testifies to our nearly unassailable capacity for denial. One of the central “characters” in Fireweather drops off some laundry at the local dry cleaner when a fellow who’d just been evacuated from one of Fort McMurray’s golf courses because of the fire comes in the store to pick up his dry cleaning. Hearing the man’s frightening news, the owner of the business frantically calls his wife to flee their house which was near the golf course. Not missing a beat, though, the owner asks the woman who’s leaving her clothes for dry cleaning whether she’d like to pick up her dry cleaning the following Tuesday. “Tuesday’s good,” she says, confident that ordinary life will be unaffected by the out-of-control wildfire that is sweeping through the city.

 

Perhaps our intellectual and emotional resistance to recognizing ecological disaster bumps shoulders with our incapacity to accept our own deaths.

 

Now to the next part of Marshall’s observation, action: what is the deep change required of us? Everyone who has even a rudimentary grasp of global warming is familiar with the dos and don’ts: eat less meat, avoid the winter vacation to the Caribbean, have fewer children. Etc. While I’ve drastically reduced air travel, I have flown (primarily to Europe for research purposes). I take trains when I can, don’t use a clothes dryer, but there are three computers in this house along with video games. We buy local as much as we can, but I must have almonds from California. Frozen edamame from China. We own a Prius, plan for one vegan day a week, buy used clothing and are careful with the air conditioner. In the winter I shovel snow into buckets and then melt it to flush the toilet. But it’s impossible to not be aware that one’s personal choices re: global warming don’t even qualify as puny, and as someone who lives in Saskatchewan, my ostensibly progressive vote generally counts for very little, almost nothing. I can give donations to ecological charities and walk to work except when the sky is smokey or it’s colder than -30 C but millions upon millions of decisions made by ordinary people in their efforts to reduce emissions were canceled out when Putin decided to invade Ukraine. Celebrities have private jets, giving credence to climate scientist Michael Mann’s observation about the inequities involved in creating emissions: “The vast proportion of historic greenhouse gases have been emitted as by-products of the choices and activities, not of the masses of ordinary people, but rather of the wealthy minority of the world’s population . . . It’s a very specific part of humanity that has created these problems” (qtd in Vaillant 312)? Of course, compared to almost everyone in the world, I qualify as a member of the wealthy minority.

 

Kant would say act ethically anyway, regardless of whether one’s choices to lessen one’s carbon footprint are inconsequential. Or even more relevant to the current historical moment, Hans Jonas updates the Kantian imperative: “Act so that the effects of your action are compatible with the permanence of genuine human life . . . Do not compromise the conditions for an indefinite continuation of humanity on earth.” But how to do this when even writing this blog on a laptop could be evaluated as compromising the quality of life for future generations? Yup, it was easier by far to ditch the cigarettes.

 

And yet, I think things are even more complicated. It’s impossible not to wonder whether attempting to act ethically is also a kind of denial insofar as it makes one feel a small degree of self-respect that one is at least doing something. Robert William Sandford speaks to this problem:

 

“If one’s self-worth and self-image—which is to say identity—has been tied to articulating a climate threat, communicating the supporting science and pressing publicly for urgent action, the realization that all you have been striving for and all you are identified with has been reduced to little more than a fool’s errand, could be devastating, especially given what such a failure would mean to the future of all humanity. After dealing with the brutal blow to one’s self-worth, the next question of course would become: What do I do now?” (The Anthropocene Disruption 92 -93).

 

Face the facts, don’t shy away from despair, Sandford offers, and read Robert Bringhurst and Jan Zwicky.

 

√  to reading Learning to Die: Wisdom in the Age of Climate Crisis.

 

*

 

Before the fire in Jasper, I’d seen many wildfires in BC, and have sat with an air purifier on in a room when the Air Quality index is 10+. (Vaillant points out that the AQ in Fort McMurray was 38 when the fire was burning.) Over the years, it’s been unclear to me how one is to manage the precarious balance between trying to acknowledge the severity of global warming and recognizing the psychological consequences of doing so. The situation seems simple enough: pondering[1] a local manifestation of global warming necessarily results in grief, fear and anger; bringing even a few of the implications to mind, such as the pain for those involved (from people to animals to forests) and dreading the future—holding these things in the head is corrosive.

 

Bringhurst and Zwicky maintain that one can “live simply, with less, and offer more to charity.” Indeed, one can do these things, and then try harder, but some days it’s difficult not to crash and lie in bed facing the wall, and not speak or move for hours—sometimes it’s been five hours or more I’ve remained in this near catatonic state. And then, afterwards, when I collect myself, I wonder whether seeking psychological well-being to offset the debilitating effects of “climate anxiety” and depression is ethically responsible. Is trying to maintain psychological health a form of escapism? I’m ashamed to say that the Jasper fire has shown me that to be able to think the question belongs to someone who has the safety of distance. I’m ashamed because it took Jasper’s destruction, a place I’ve frequently visited, to feel global warming as a new sort of hurt, a kind that won’t go away no matter what I do to work at psychological health. Put plainly, I’ve heard the vivifying and astonishing sound of ice cracking in the cold air around the Edith Cavell glacier just south of Jasper: how much of it is left after the fire went through? How many livelihoods in the town itself were destroyed and how much animal and plant life in the environs has been lost?

 

And now, after the climate protests, the letters to politicians, the classes on the environment taught and conversations with climate-deniers, the books written, here it comes again: a microdose of panic blooms into flaring anxiety. I’ve just called Ecojustice to make a small increase in my monthly donation and must somehow teach myself to face things, resist my natural inclination to close the door and the curtains and go to bed and lie facing the wall.

 

*

 

Fireweather isn’t simply a demanding, stressful read; I’d expected the book to be a well-written piece of investigative journalism, which it is, but I hadn’t anticipated its wide-ranging philosophical and literary interests. Encouraging the reader to try thinking “like a fire,” and placing what happened in Fort McMurray within the context of Beowulf, Orson Welles’s broadcast of War of the Worlds, Allied bombing raids on Germany and Japan during World War II, Fireweather insists that we must rethink not merely our economic dependence on fossil fuels but our relationship with reality. A fire mutates ontology, according to Vaillant, turning a house into a bomb; language stalls and invents intricate nomenclature and artistic forms to account for the uncontainable nature of new weather events, new forms of loss. In some ways, the book is to our dangerous and ever-more-out-of-control historical moment what James Agee and Walker Evans’s Let Us Now Praise Famous Men was to poverty and financial inequity of the 1930s. Agee wanted to break literary form, often inserting jarring lists to jolt readers from the solitude and safety of holding a book to face lives quite different from their own. Different landscapes, different tools, rougher crockery and a more turbulent kind of sky. As he puts it, “If I could do it, I’d do no writing at all here. It would be photographs; the rest would be fragments of cloth, bits of cotton, lumps of earth, records of speech, pieces of wood and iron, phials of odors, plates of food and excrement.” I suspect that Vaillant would be sympathetic to what Agee was after: disturbing the reader. People had to flee Fort McMurray, and in describing the necessity for them to do so, Vaillant offers a startling collection of objects they took with them:

 

“Those who had the time to grab a few belongings made choices they would have trouble explaining later. Among more plausible belongings were found snow pants, low-fat cheese, a mounted bear’s head, chocolate Easter eggs, a propane tank, a samurai sword, empty bottles, an encyclopedia of gardening. The rest was left to the whims of the fire.”

 

Viewed in one way, this list is a microcosm of the absurdities attached to a certain form of middle-class life; from another perspective, confused terror joins these inarticulate and bizarre objects. What would I take? You? There are all sorts of terror handed to the reader of this book. Perhaps the worst is when Vaillant describes how oil executives knew for decades that their industry would cause global warming. (They knew long before the general public.) Initially these CEOs thought that their companies should take precautions, but they then changed their minds and decided to engage in a campaign of disinformation. The American Petroleum Institute’s “decision to turn its back on a century of solid climate science,” Vaillant writes, “is proving to be the most consequential policy reversal in the history of human civilization.”

 


[1]I use the word “pondering” deliberately to evoke David Foster Wallace’s excoriation of the ponderer in Infinite Jest: “Gately’s snapped to the fact that people of a certain age and level of life-experience believe they’re immortal: college students and alcoholics/addicts are the worst: they deep-down believe they’re exempt from the laws of physics and statistics that ironly govern everyone else. They’ll piss and moan your ear off if somebody fucks with the rules, but they don’t deep down see themselves subject to them, the same rules. And they’re constitutionally unable to learn from anybody else’s experience; if some jaywalking B.U. student does get splattered on Comm. or some House resident does get his car towed at 0005, your other student’s or addict’s response to this will be to ponder just what imponderable difference makes it possible for that other guy to get splattered or towed and not him, the ponderer. They never doubt the difference—they just ponder it. It’s like a kind of idolatry of uniqueness” (604).

Previous
Previous

They

Next
Next

On Fragments